cache exists in db Search - ManaHive
Helper

MANAHIVE

Newest Sets:
Marvel Super Heroes Secrets of Strixhaven Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Year of the Horse 2026 Lorwyn Eclipsed MagicFest 2026 Wizards Play Network 2026 Avatar: The Last Airbender Marvel Universe Marvel's Spider-Man

🤖 ManaHive AI

"Find me cards equivalent to: Bag of Holding"

Equivalent colorless artifact cards to Bag of Holding with similar discard and/or card recursion features:
1. Conjuror's Closet – Exiles and returns creatures, useful for recursion, but not for hand.
2. Elixir of Immortality – Shuffles graveyard into the library, some recursion.
3. Silent Gravestone – Exiles graveyards, some overlap.
4. Perpetual Timepiece – Mills then recurs any number of cards from graveyard.
5. Scrabbling Claws – Exiles cards from graveyard, some overlap.

Closest true equivalents with discard/exile/return for colorless are Perpetual Timepiece and Scrabbling Claws. None have all Bag of Holding abilities, but these offer similar recursion/interaction.

Found Cards

5 Results

Bag of Holding

Elixir of Immortality

Perpetual Timepiece

Scrabbling Claws

Silent Gravestone

Bag of Holding #222p Artifact

Variations: v1 v2
Find Cards Like Bag of Holding

Info

Color:
Identifies:
Cost:
Rarity: Rare
Converted Cost: 1
Power/Toughness: /
Types:
  • Artifact
    • SubTypes:
    Languages:
    Layout:
    Normal
    Rank:
    Saltiness:

    Rules

  • If Bag of Holding is moved to exile when you sacrifice it (most likely due to Leyline of the Void's effect), it remains in exile. It won't be returned to your hand.
  • If Bag of Holding leaves the battlefield, the items it contained are exiled forever (and, perhaps, scattered throughout the Astral Plane). If the same Bag of Holding card returns to the battlefield, it's considered a new object without access to the cards stored by the old object.
  • If you control more than one Bag of Holding, you choose which one will hold the discarded card. Other Bags of Holding can't return that card.
  • If you discard a card but that card is not in your graveyard as Bag of Holding's first ability resolves, that card remains wherever it has moved.
  • You both draw and discard while Bag of Holding's second ability is resolving. No player may take any action—nor can anything else happen—until you've both drawn and discarded.

    • Prices

    Seller Price
    Manapool / 1.56 USD 0.89 USD
    Tcgplayer / 1.69 USD 0.86 USD
    Cardkingdom 0.99 USD
    Cardmarket 0.21 EUR / 0.64 EUR

    Legalities

    Alchemy Brawl Commander Duel Future Gladiator Historic Legacy Modern Oathbreaker Oldschool Pauper Paupercommander Penny Pioneer Predh Premodern Standard Standardbrawl Timeless Vintage

    Text

    Whenever youdiscarda card, exile that card from your graveyard. , : Draw a card, thendiscarda card. , ,Sacrificethis artifact: Return all cards exiled with this artifact to their owner's hand.

    Elixir of Immortality #1634 Artifact

    Variations: v1 v2
    Find Cards Like Elixir of Immortality

    Info

    Color:
    Identifies:
    Cost:
    Rarity: Rare
    Converted Cost: 1
    Power/Toughness: /
    Types:
  • Artifact
    • SubTypes:
    Languages:
    Layout:
    Normal
    Rank:
    Saltiness:

    Rules

  • Paying the activation cost of Elixir of Immortality’s ability doesn’t cause it to leave the battlefield. If you have a way to untap it, you can activate the ability multiple times in response to itself.
  • As the ability resolves, you’ll shuffle Elixir of Immortality into its owner’s library directly from the battlefield, if it’s still there.
  • If Elixir of Immortality is in your graveyard at the time the ability resolves, you’ll still wind up shuffling it into your library because you shuffle your entire graveyard into your library. If it’s anywhere else by that time, including in another player’s graveyard, it remains where it is and you shuffle just your graveyard into your library.
  • If you gain control of another player’s Elixir of Immortality and activate it, the Elixir of Immortality will be shuffled into its owner’s library and the cards in your graveyard will be shuffled into your library. You are considered to have shuffled each affected library (even if, as a shortcut, each player physically shuffles their own library).

    • Prices

    Seller Price
    Cardkingdom / 5.49 USD 7.49 USD
    Cardmarket / 4.51 EUR 3.21 EUR
    Tcgplayer 7.04 USD
    Manapool 5.81 USD

    Legalities

    Alchemy Brawl Commander Duel Future Gladiator Historic Legacy Modern Oathbreaker Oldschool Pauper Paupercommander Penny Pioneer Predh Premodern Standard Standardbrawl Timeless Vintage

    Text

    , : You gain 5 life.Shufflethis artifact and your graveyard into their owner's library.

    Perpetual Timepiece #354 Artifact

    Find Cards Like Perpetual Timepiece

    Info

    Color:
    Identifies:
    Cost:
    Rarity: Uncommon
    Converted Cost: 2
    Power/Toughness: /
    Types:
  • Artifact
    • SubTypes:
    Languages:
    Layout:
    Normal
    Rank:
    Saltiness:

    Abilities/Keywords

    Mill

    Rules

  • You can activate Perpetual Timepiece's second ability with no targets just to shuffle your library. If you choose any targets and they all become illegal targets, the ability won't resolve and you won't shuffle your library.

    • Prices

    Seller Price
    Cardmarket 0.23 EUR
    Tcgplayer 0.25 USD
    Manapool 0.15 USD
    Cardkingdom 0.35 USD

    Legalities

    Alchemy Brawl Commander Duel Future Gladiator Historic Legacy Modern Oathbreaker Oldschool Pauper Paupercommander Penny Pioneer Predh Premodern Standard Standardbrawl Timeless Vintage

    Text

    :Milltwo cards. (Put the top two cards of your library into your graveyard.) , Exile this artifact:Shuffleany number of target cards from your graveyard into your library.

    Scrabbling Claws #jn237sb Artifact

    Variations: v1 v2
    Find Cards Like Scrabbling Claws

    Info

    Color:
    Identifies:
    Cost:
    Rarity: Uncommon
    Converted Cost: 1
    Power/Toughness: /
    Types:
  • Artifact
    • SubTypes:
    Languages:
    Layout:
    Normal
    Rank:
    Saltiness:

    Rules

  • No entries

    • Prices

    Seller Price
    Manapool 0.2 USD
    Cardkingdom 0.35 USD
    Cardmarket 0.26 EUR

    Legalities

    Alchemy Brawl Commander Duel Future Gladiator Historic Legacy Modern Oathbreaker Oldschool Pauper Paupercommander Penny Pioneer Predh Premodern Standard Standardbrawl Timeless Vintage

    Text

    : Target player exiles a card from their graveyard. ,Sacrificethis artifact: Exile target card from a graveyard. Draw a card.

    Silent Gravestone #182s Artifact

    Variations: v1 v2
    Find Cards Like Silent Gravestone

    Info

    Color:
    Identifies:
    Cost:
    Rarity: Rare
    Converted Cost: 1
    Power/Toughness: /
    Types:
  • Artifact
    • SubTypes:
    Languages:
    Layout:
    Normal
    Rank:
    Saltiness:

    Rules

  • Only spells and abilities that target cards in graveyards will be affected. Spells and abilities that affect cards in graveyards without targeting them (such as Extract from Darkness) can still affect those cards.
  • Silent Gravestone isn’t exiled until its activated ability resolves.

    • Prices

    Seller Price
    Manapool 1.92 USD
    Tcgplayer 1.92 USD
    Cardkingdom 3.99 USD
    Cardmarket 1.15 EUR

    Legalities

    Alchemy Brawl Commander Duel Future Gladiator Historic Legacy Modern Oathbreaker Oldschool Pauper Paupercommander Penny Pioneer Predh Premodern Standard Standardbrawl Timeless Vintage

    Text

    Cards in graveyards can't be the targets of spells or abilities. , : Exile this artifact and all cards from all graveyards. Draw a card.