MANAHIVE
Newest Sets:
🤖 ManaHive AI
"Find me cards equivalent to: Tortured Existence"
Equivalent cards to Tortured Existence (Black, graveyard recursion, discard/trade for creature):
- Skull Prophet: Self-mill and mana, less direct, black/green.
- Phyrexian Reclamation: Pays life and mana to return creatures.
- Hell's Caretaker: Sacrifice for recursion at upkeep.
- Whisper, Blood Liturgist: Sacrifice two creatures to return one.
- Omen of the Dead: Single-use, instant return.
Reason: All are black (some multicolor), focus on getting creatures back from the graveyard. None are as efficient or repeatable as Tortured Existence, but fill similar roles.
Found Cards
6 Results
Hell's Caretaker #92 Creature — Horror
Info
| Color: |  |
| Identifies: | |
| Cost: |
  |
| Rarity: | Rare |
| Converted Cost: | 4 |
| Power/Toughness: | 1/1 |
| Types: | |
| SubTypes: | |
| Languages: | 
   |
| Layout: | Normal |
| Rank: | |
| Saltiness: |
Rules
Prices
Legalities
Alchemy
Brawl
Commander
Duel
Future
Gladiator
Historic
Legacy
Modern
Oathbreaker
Oldschool
Pauper
Paupercommander
Penny
Pioneer
Predh
Premodern
Standard
Standardbrawl
Timeless
Vintage
Text
,Sacrificea creature: Return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield. Activate only during your upkeep.
Hell's Caretaker
Omen of the Dead #110 Enchantment
Info
| Color: | |
| Identifies: | |
| Cost: |
|
| Rarity: | Common |
| Converted Cost: | 1 |
| Power/Toughness: | / |
| Types: | |
| SubTypes: | |
| Languages: |
      |
| Layout: | Normal |
| Rank: | |
| Saltiness: |
Abilities/Keywords
Flash
Scry
Rules
Prices
Legalities
Alchemy
Brawl
Commander
Duel
Future
Gladiator
Historic
Legacy
Modern
Oathbreaker
Oldschool
Pauper
Paupercommander
Penny
Pioneer
Predh
Premodern
Standard
Standardbrawl
Timeless
Vintage
Text
Flash When this enchantment enters, return target creature card from your graveyard to your hand.
,Sacrificethis enchantment: Scry 2.
Omen of the Dead
Phyrexian Reclamation #1808 Enchantment
Info
| Color: | |
| Identifies: | |
| Cost: |
|
| Rarity: | Rare |
| Converted Cost: | 1 |
| Power/Toughness: | / |
| Types: | |
| SubTypes: | |
| Languages: |
|
| Layout: | Normal |
| Rank: | |
| Saltiness: |
Rules
Prices
Legalities
Alchemy
Brawl
Commander
Duel
Future
Gladiator
Historic
Legacy
Modern
Oathbreaker
Oldschool
Pauper
Paupercommander
Penny
Pioneer
Predh
Premodern
Standard
Standardbrawl
Timeless
Vintage
Text
, Pay 2 life: Return target creature card from your graveyard to your hand.
Phyrexian Reclamation
Skull Prophet #304 Creature — Human Druid
Info
| Color: |  |
| Identifies: | |
| Cost: |
 |
| Rarity: | Uncommon |
| Converted Cost: | 2 |
| Power/Toughness: | 3/1 |
| Types: | |
| SubTypes: | |
| Languages: |
|
| Layout: | Normal |
| Rank: | |
| Saltiness: |
Abilities/Keywords
Mill
Rules
Text
: Add or .
:Milltwo cards. (Put the top two cards of your library into your graveyard.)
Skull Prophet
Tortured Existence #2507 Enchantment
Info
| Color: | |
| Identifies: | |
| Cost: |
|
| Rarity: | Rare |
| Converted Cost: | 1 |
| Power/Toughness: | / |
| Types: | |
| SubTypes: | |
| Languages: |
|
| Layout: | Normal |
| Rank: | |
| Saltiness: |
Rules
Text
,Discarda creature card: Return target creature card from your graveyard to your hand.
Tortured Existence
Whisper, Blood Liturgist #111s Legendary Creature — Human Cleric
Info
| Color: | |
| Identifies: | |
| Cost: |
|
| Rarity: | Uncommon |
| Converted Cost: | 4 |
| Power/Toughness: | 2/2 |
| Types: | |
| SubTypes: | |
| Languages: |
|
| Layout: | Normal |
| Rank: | |
| Saltiness: |
Rules
Text
,Sacrificetwo creatures: Return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield.
Whisper, Blood Liturgist
Hell's Caretaker #92 Creature — Horror
Info
| Color: | |
| Identifies: | |
| Cost: |
|
| Rarity: | Rare |
| Converted Cost: | 4 |
| Power/Toughness: | 1/1 |
| Types: | |
| SubTypes: | |
| Languages: |
|
| Layout: | Normal |
| Rank: | |
| Saltiness: |
Rules
Prices
Legalities
Alchemy
Brawl
Commander
Duel
Future
Gladiator
Historic
Legacy
Modern
Oathbreaker
Oldschool
Pauper
Paupercommander
Penny
Pioneer
Predh
Premodern
Standard
Standardbrawl
Timeless
Vintage
Text
,Sacrificea creature: Return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield. Activate only during your upkeep. Omen of the Dead #110 Enchantment
Info
| Color: | |
| Identifies: | |
| Cost: |
|
| Rarity: | Common |
| Converted Cost: | 1 |
| Power/Toughness: | / |
| Types: | |
| SubTypes: | |
| Languages: |
|
| Layout: | Normal |
| Rank: | |
| Saltiness: |
Abilities/Keywords
Flash
Scry
Rules
Prices
Legalities
Alchemy
Brawl
Commander
Duel
Future
Gladiator
Historic
Legacy
Modern
Oathbreaker
Oldschool
Pauper
Paupercommander
Penny
Pioneer
Predh
Premodern
Standard
Standardbrawl
Timeless
Vintage
Text
Flash When this enchantment enters, return target creature card from your graveyard to your hand.,Sacrificethis enchantment: Scry 2. Phyrexian Reclamation #1808 Enchantment
Info
| Color: | |
| Identifies: | |
| Cost: |
|
| Rarity: | Rare |
| Converted Cost: | 1 |
| Power/Toughness: | / |
| Types: | |
| SubTypes: | |
| Languages: |
|
| Layout: | Normal |
| Rank: | |
| Saltiness: |
Rules
Prices
Legalities
Alchemy
Brawl
Commander
Duel
Future
Gladiator
Historic
Legacy
Modern
Oathbreaker
Oldschool
Pauper
Paupercommander
Penny
Pioneer
Predh
Premodern
Standard
Standardbrawl
Timeless
Vintage
Text
, Pay 2 life: Return target creature card from your graveyard to your hand. Skull Prophet #304 Creature — Human Druid
Info
| Color: | |
| Identifies: | |
| Cost: |
|
| Rarity: | Uncommon |
| Converted Cost: | 2 |
| Power/Toughness: | 3/1 |
| Types: | |
| SubTypes: | |
| Languages: |
|
| Layout: | Normal |
| Rank: | |
| Saltiness: |
Abilities/Keywords
Mill
Rules
Text
: Add or .
:Milltwo cards. (Put the top two cards of your library into your graveyard.) Tortured Existence #2507 Enchantment
Info
| Color: | |
| Identifies: | |
| Cost: |
|
| Rarity: | Rare |
| Converted Cost: | 1 |
| Power/Toughness: | / |
| Types: | |
| SubTypes: | |
| Languages: |
|
| Layout: | Normal |
| Rank: | |
| Saltiness: |
Rules
Text
,Discarda creature card: Return target creature card from your graveyard to your hand. Whisper, Blood Liturgist #111s Legendary Creature — Human Cleric
Info
| Color: | |
| Identifies: | |
| Cost: |
|
| Rarity: | Uncommon |
| Converted Cost: | 4 |
| Power/Toughness: | 2/2 |
| Types: | |
| SubTypes: | |
| Languages: |
|
| Layout: | Normal |
| Rank: | |
| Saltiness: |
Rules
Text
,Sacrificetwo creatures: Return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield.